The WoodenBoat Forum

The WoodenBoat Forum (http://www.woodenboat.com/forum//index.php)
-   The Bilge (http://www.woodenboat.com/forum//forumdisplay.php?f=5)
-   -   Doctor's visit (http://www.woodenboat.com/forum//showthread.php?t=106536)

jack grebe 12-05-2009 04:58 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Norman Bernstein (Post 2410506)
I wonder if the courtroom has a ramp for wheelchairs?

If not, I am sure there will be more than a few animal
lovers there willing to kick his arse up the steps:rolleyes:.

Bobby 12-05-2009 05:02 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
This thread must be to his advantage. you have never seen him leave one alone this long. You dont hear Scot sayin nothin:(

Duncan Gibbs 12-05-2009 05:44 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by johnw (Post 2411372)
All right, George, you've got the attention you crave. Now poof the thread and be done with it.

If George is proved innocent then what makes this thread any different from any one of us who posts threads asking for good thoughts and sympathy. Let's all live by the principles that we all think make the Western World so bloody amazing - rule of law and that sort of stuff - and let the guy have his day in court.

Bobby 12-05-2009 05:55 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
this is why. http://www.newson6.com/Global/story.asp?S=11621125

Lew Barrett 12-05-2009 06:04 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
It's not solely in respect to the unmentionable issue at hand that there is such a lack of regard for the subject and OP, but I agree with Johnw. Poof it.

Phillip Allen 12-05-2009 06:08 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bobby (Post 2411421)

what makes us humans so blood-hungry? it seems most think in terms of revenge

Duncan Gibbs 12-05-2009 06:18 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bobby (Post 2411421)

I'll take that as a vote for vigilantism. Good stuff eh?

What's this case got to do with George anyhoo? Is this the judge who is presiding?

botebum 12-05-2009 06:21 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Duncan Gibbs (Post 2411449)
Is this the judge who is presiding?

No, but the Judge is one of GR's neighbors. Must be something in the water in Broken Arrow that causes brutality to be accepted behaviour.

Doug

Bobby 12-05-2009 06:22 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Phillip Allen (Post 2411436)
what makes us humans so blood-hungry? it seems most think in terms of revenge

To me it is about the law, not revenge. You do not accidently bash a baby to death. Is it about money,friends, threats. I dont know. The judge said he had no history of violence. So do we kill one baby (dog) or two before we pay our debt to society??

Phillip Allen 12-05-2009 06:26 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bobby (Post 2411451)
To me it is about the law, not revenge. You do not accidently bash a baby to death. Is it about money,friends, threats. I dont know. The judge said he had no history of violence. So do we kill one baby (dog) or two before we pay our debt to society??

okay...if it's about the law, how do you explain your disregard for the law?

StevenBauer 12-05-2009 06:32 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Duncan Gibbs (Post 2411414)
If George is proved innocent ....


He already admitted here that he did it. If he pleas down or gets off on a technicality it won't change the facts of what happened.

I was very surprised this thread was still here this morning. More surprised it's lasted all day.

Steven

Bobby 12-05-2009 06:33 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Duncan Gibbs (Post 2411449)
I'll take that as a vote for vigilantism. Good stuff eh?

What's this case got to do with George anyhoo? Is this the judge who is presiding?

I really dont give a rats ass about George. I just want the world to know Justice will not prevail. Why do you think this has went on for so long. Wittnesses forget, judges change. Prioreties change. Today its pot then its theft. Animal cruelty, the shelters are full, foster homes are full, Maybe he did us all a favor. How about an award for George!!!!!

Bobby 12-05-2009 06:35 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Phillip Allen (Post 2411453)
okay...if it's about the law, how do you explain your disregard for the law?

My disregard? please explain:(

Phillip Allen 12-05-2009 06:37 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bobby (Post 2411460)
My disregard? please explain:(

easy...the LAW says "innocent until PROVEN guilty" It would seem that particular facet of law is an inconvience for you

Bobby 12-05-2009 06:49 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Phillip Allen (Post 2411464)
easy...the LAW says "innocent until PROVEN guilty" It would seem that particular facet of law is an inconvience for you

Do you always asume so much.I dont know who you are talking about. The man I spoke of Bashed a baby against a dresser, ruptured its liver and it died. End of story. Jury said it was muder gave him life in prison. The judge said he did not think it was that bad. What do you think? It is the justice system I dont trust.

Duncan Gibbs 12-05-2009 06:52 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by StevenBauer (Post 2411458)
He already admitted here that he did it.

I missed that Steven. Was the admission implicit, explicit or divined? If it was explicit then his original plea is wrong and he deserves all the schtick he gets until his debt is officially paid.

If was either of the last two then we should wait for the wheels of law to turn full circle.

Duncan Gibbs 12-05-2009 06:57 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bobby (Post 2411472)
Do you always asume so much.I dont know who you are talking about. The man I spoke of Bashed a baby against a dresser, ruptured its liver and it died. End of story. Jury said it was muder gave him life in prison. The judge said he did not think it was that bad. What do you think? It is the justice system I dont trust.

One, or two, or even twenty cases that have gone sour do not, a system broke, make. If you prefer the alternative to the rule of law then go live in an anarchic or totalitarian state.

Phillip Allen 12-05-2009 07:02 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Duncan Gibbs (Post 2411479)
One, or two, or even twenty cases that have gone sour do not, a system broke, make. If you prefer the alternative to the rule of law then go live in an anarchic or totalitarian state.

Damn Duncan...I'm feeling wierd with us on the same side...I wonder if this makes me a wennie too :)

Bobby 12-05-2009 07:03 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Oh ya, In case you missed it PHILLIP, I really dont give a rats ass about George. I listened to him tell the pople at Bear Mountian Boat shop how stupid they were. I think they are still in business. He flaunts what he did in everyones face. And now he has some new Idea of how to use the forum. If he is innocent or guilty It will not mean one thing to me. O,I for got On that other thread You said if it was the wrong verdict it would effect us all. Think about it. Again where is SCOT?

Phillip Allen 12-05-2009 07:13 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Scot isn't needed here...so far...you just want a bit of childish indulgence for yourself...I'd bet he doesn't want to hear any of us calling for "Momma, make him stop"

did I ever say I don't like lynch mobs?

Duncan Gibbs 12-05-2009 07:16 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Phillip Allen (Post 2411481)
Damn Duncan...I'm feeling wierd with us on the same side...I wonder if this makes me a wennie too :)

Savour that feeling Phillip! Make last!!!

BTW, I'm proud to be a wennie, but I'm glad I'm not a weenie!! :D:D

Bobby 12-05-2009 07:22 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Phillip Allen (Post 2411488)
Scot isn't needed here...so far...you just want a bit of childish indulgence for yourself...I'd bet he doesn't want to hear any of us calling for "Momma, make him stop"

did I ever say I don't like lynch mobs?

I dont need momma or Scot. How many times has this forum heard you say you cant Trust the law. You remind me of a big old crawdad.

Bobby 12-05-2009 07:40 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Hey Phillip I heard this neat poem to day, I thought that you might have written it. Aint no problem that cant be fixed. With a little bit of patience and a 3006. At least out to about five hundred yards:):):)

Phillip Allen 12-05-2009 08:19 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
say goodnight Gracie...

paladin 12-05-2009 08:30 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Goodnight, Gracie...

botebum 12-05-2009 09:28 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
I think that George should have his day in court. After that, we can all be done with this or we can bash the hell out of him with rightiousness. Will Monday be the day? History shows that GR and his lawyer(s) have been able to postpone the date time and again. Sounds like everyone wants George to have his day in court except George. In itself, that doesn't make George guilty. Legally, it doesn't even imply it. In a public forum, it looks pretty shady. We are not the court of law to which George is entitled. We are his peers. We calls 'em like we sees 'em. If George doesn't like what people think of him then maybe he should refrain from posting on a public forum. WB's responsibility ended on this subject long ago in my thinking. They protected him from the members and probably warned him that his posting would stir controversy. He continued to post so it's all on him now. It's a public forum with free membership. WBF should hold no responsibility after warning George of his self-inflicted abuse. Keep posting George. It's all up to you. Realize that you have no real friends here. You helped to ruin that long before this alleged incident with your holier than thou attitude. Guilty or not, I hope you go away.

Doug

Doug

TimH 12-05-2009 09:37 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
He is practicing his woa-is-me dont you feel sorry for me tactic before the big day.

And yes Duncan. He admitted it. He cant be proven innocent.

Saltiguy 12-05-2009 10:24 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
I'm sorry to see this all raised up again prior to a official verdict.
When my son was in Cub Scouts, his Leader was arrested for "touching" (sexual assault) one of the boys. It's a long story, but I just happened to know the real story from my son, a few of his friends, and a Police friend of mine who told me the whole sorry mess about what really DIDN'T happen. This guy was TOTALLY innocent. He was a good guy who did NOTHING wrong. Nevertheless, he was railroaded into accepting a plea to a lesser charge, branded a sex offender, and given years of probation and community service. His family business was ruined, and he left town a broken man.
Don't judge, and don't ever think it couldn't happen to you.

Michael s/v Sannyasin 12-05-2009 10:26 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
GR is guilty, and he knows precisely what of. His bike 'accident' flowed out of the consciousness that followed his reprehensible actions. Boo-hoo. If he keeps up his arrogant attitude, then he'll just keep experiencing these little 'accidents' for the rest of his life. I suspect that is the way it will continue.

On the other hand, I know that even the most evil people can make ammends... by significant effort in the opposite direction. So, George could stand up in court, admit everything, and make a sizable donation to an animal shelter or rescue society. If he did... then I think that he would be surprised at how there were many less accidents waiting to happen around him...

But... I won't hold my breath...

And Duncan... nobody cares what you think anyway...

PeterSibley 12-05-2009 10:30 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Duncan Gibbs (Post 2411476)
I missed that Steven. Was the admission implicit, explicit or divined? If it was explicit then his original plea is wrong and he deserves all the schtick he gets until his debt is officially paid.

If was either of the last two then we should wait for the wheels of law to turn full circle.

Explicit .

George has had a compassion bypass .

Norman Bernstein 12-05-2009 10:35 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Saltiguy (Post 2411635)
I'm sorry to see this all raised up again prior to a official verdict.
When my son was in Cub Scouts, his Leader was arrested for "touching" (sexual assault) one of the boys. It's a long story, but I just happened to know the real story from my son, a few of his friends, and a Police friend of mine who told me the whole sorry mess about what really DIDN'T happen. This guy was TOTALLY innocent. He was a good guy who did NOTHING wrong. Nevertheless, he was railroaded into accepting a plea to a lesser charge, branded a sex offender, and given years of probation and community service. His family business was ruined, and he left town a broken man.
Don't judge, and don't ever think it couldn't happen to you.

Speaking purely hypothetically, it seems to me that there are two types of innocense, in law: cases where the defendant is accused of something he actually didn't do, and cases where the defendant has esentially admitted the act, but the intricacies of the law result in a verdict of innocense.

I think it's possible, and even necessary, to accept both kinds of judgments.

However, there's a court of public opinion, too... and it doesn't always correspond to the verdict handed down in a court. We are obliged to live by the court verdict... but we are entitled to make our own judgment about the guilt or innocense of the defendant, outside the domain of the court. So, if someone gets off by virtue of a technicality... or if the verdict and resulting punishment seem disproportional to the crime, there's not a thing wrong with deciding for ourselves whether justice was served or not.

TimH 12-05-2009 10:36 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Michael s/v Sannyasin (Post 2411638)
GR is guilty, and he knows precisely what of. His bike 'accident' flowed out of the consciousness that followed his reprehensible actions. Boo-hoo. If he keeps up his arrogant attitude, then he'll just keep experiencing these little 'accidents' for the rest of his life. I suspect that is the way it will continue.

On the other hand, I know that even the most evil people can make ammends... by significant effort in the opposite direction. So, George could stand up in court, admit everything, and make a sizable donation to an animal shelter or rescue society. If he did... then I think that he would be surprised at how there were many less accidents waiting to happen around him...

But... I won't hold my breath...

And Duncan... nobody cares what you think anyway...

What a great post! I agree 100%

shamus 12-05-2009 11:01 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
This thread up the top again?
Against my better judgement I'll add a contribution, since I am a brilliant thread killer. First to rebut M s/v S, I care what Duncan thinks. Second, I'll await the verdict. Third, people are innocent until found guilty, but sometimes one has knowledge which entitles a private judgement. In my opinion private judgements ought to remain private, if you want live in a decent society. Otherwise the journey to the lynching is a short one.

TimH 12-05-2009 11:04 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
people are only innocent until they admit they are guilty. After that they cannot be considered innocent anymore. No matter what the judge says.

Norman Bernstein 12-05-2009 11:11 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by shamus (Post 2411666)
In my opinion private judgements ought to remain private, if you want live in a decent society. Otherwise the journey to the lynching is a short one.

I understand the basic sentiment you're expressing, but I can't agree. There's a huge gap between expressing one's opinion, and the 'lynching' you're referring to. We ALL have opinions and judgments, and none of us should be afraid to express them... as long as that's all we're doing with our opinions.

Michael s/v Sannyasin 12-05-2009 11:48 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
I agree with TimH. GR has admitted to the deed. I for one, am not hoping to exact any punishment (re: lynching) of GR. Karma takes care of that. It's not my place or responsibility. Awful coincidence how that driver smashed into him though, isn't it?

I'm just pointing out to George that (to quote Ben Kingsly in the movie Ghandi) "I know a way out of hell". If he wants it, it is there. I don't expect him to ever care enough to avail himself of it though.

George Jung 12-05-2009 11:51 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
I'm afraid Michael pretty much nailed it!

But George should/will get his day in court.

bobbys 12-05-2009 11:55 PM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Ransom Stoddard: Marshal, I was wrong the other day. But I was reading up on territorial law, and there it is, right there. Now, I'll draw up the complaint, take care of all the legal details - but you *do* have jurisdiction. Says so right there. So next time he sets foot in this town, you'll arrest him.
Link Appleyard: Anything you say, Mr. Stoddard. I'll be tickled to... death... *what* was that? Arrest *who*?
Ransom Stoddard: Liberty Valance.
Link Appleyard: Arrest Liberty Val... you mean Liberty Valance? Just as I was startin' to get my appetite back.

TerryLL 12-06-2009 12:04 AM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by George Roberts (Post 2410327)
I had a 9:40 appointment with my surgeon to get x-rays and evaluation of my current condition.Usually my wife and daughter go with me. It is a fun outing.But my wife and daughter had continuing professional education (CPE) today - 8-5.So my wife says "I will drop you off at 7:30 and pick you up at 5:30. Be sure to pack a lunch." I hang a red cloth grocery bag around my neck and pack food and something to do for the day into it.I got dropped off at 7:30. 18 degrees an me in shorts. I hobble inside using my walker with a red cloth grocery bag around my neck. Push the elevator button. The elevator doors don't stay open long enough for me to hobble from the button to the door. But I worked it out.The doctor's office (8 doctors perhaps 50 chairs in the waiting room) opens at 8. I check in. A little after 8, my name is called. Of course, I am sitting out of sight of the person calling my name. But I get escorted back to a patient room hobbling all the way. X-ray tech comes in to get me. I hobble back to his machine. He takes a dozen pictures. We talk about his machine. About my accident. We go back to my room - me hobbling all the way. He looks at the x-rays. He even shows them to me. The pelvis looks great. Left thigh looks great. Despite his assurance that the right thigh looks great to me it looks terrible - like I would need more surgery.I go into my room while tech and a nurse look at the pictures both commenting on how good the pictures look.Surgeon comes in a few minutes later. Tells me how good the pictures look. Says I am building bone very fast. I suggest the right thigh looks bad. He suggests cosmetic surgery to fix the ugly bones - no guarantee that I will be able to use my leg again. :)We spoke about 15-20 minutes about the next few weeks of healing. Riding on my bicycle trainer, 50% weight bearing for a couple weeks then full weight bearing, no more brace, and massaging of my thigh.I check out. I hobble down to the wrong people for checking out. I have to backtrack - hobbling. I am all done and ready to go home before 9. I call my wife and tell her what happened. She says She will come by on break, call me when she gets close, and take me back to her CPE. Fine. As I am sitting there waiting for her to call in she walks. Mad. The phone I had was on silent. I hobble out to the car. "Faster, faster." We get to the hotel for CPE. She abandons me in the parking lot - she only wanted to use my handicapped placard.I hobble to the nearest doors. Very heavy doors. A nice fellow - who knew my wife, helped me through the doors. I found where my wife's class was and found a chair I could get up from.One three occasions I got up and hobbled around the hotel. Looked the water feature in the lobby - waterfall, stream, and pond; fish, turtles. Walked around the 8th floor balcony. Every time I came back my wife was looking for me. Around 12:20 my wife got fed up with me and took me home. I hobbled out to get the paper, hobbled to the mail box - got a bicycle bottom bracket tool. Dropped all my stuff inside. Put the bicycle tool into my red cloth bag. Hobbled out to the garage and shop. Gathered up some other tools and what is left of my bicycle frame. Took the bottom bracket off. Put the parts with the rest of the salvageable parts. Put the tools away. (Made the mistake of trying to put the tools in my van. The doors were locked and I did not have keys.) Ate lunch.Not a bad trip to the doctor.

My opinion is that we need to take up a collection and buy GR a thesaurus.

PeterSibley 12-06-2009 12:30 AM

Re: Doctor's visit
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by shamus (Post 2411666)
This thread up the top again?
Against my better judgement I'll add a contribution, since I am a brilliant thread killer. First to rebut M s/v S, I care what Duncan thinks. Second, I'll await the verdict. Third, people are innocent until found guilty, but sometimes one has knowledge which entitles a private judgement. In my opinion private judgements ought to remain private, if you want live in a decent society. Otherwise the journey to the lynching is a short one.

Fortunately virtual rope isn't fatal .


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:05 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright WoodenBoat Publications, 2009